Want Better Performance? Start With a Better 1:1 Meeting

---

When performance slips, most leaders look for a new tool, a faster process, or a tougher target. But in my experience, one of the most effective ways to improve team performance doesn’t cost anything. It doesn’t require a platform. And it’s not a new initiative.

It’s a consistent, well-run 1:1 meeting.

Most teams already hold them. Some do them sporadically. A few avoid them altogether. But very few do them well. That’s a missed opportunity, because 1:1s, when used intentionally, are one of the simplest ways to improve alignment, build trust, and solve small problems before they become big ones.

If you want better performance, start with a better 1:1.

The Most Under-utilized Performance Tool in Your Business

A 1:1 is not a check-in. It’s not a project review. It’s not something you hold only when things are off track.

It’s a protected space for a manager and a direct report to connect about the work, the challenges, and the person doing the work. When they happen regularly and with the right focus, 1:1s become a habit that anchors clarity, accountability, and support.

And they have a real impact.

✅ Employees who have regular, meaningful 1:1s are nearly 3x more likely to be engaged in their work,

✅ Teams with strong manager check-ins see 31% higher retention,

✅ And managers who use 1:1s to coach instead of micromanage build more agile, more resilient teams.

(Sources: Gallup, Officevibe, Harvard Business Review)

So if your managers are skipping these conversations, or if they’re treating them like task updates, you’re likely seeing the effects in unclear priorities, lower morale, and uneven performance.

Strong 1:1s don’t happen by accident. Here’s what they tend to have in common:

1. They happen consistently

Weekly or biweekly is best. But consistency matters more than frequency. Skipping a 1:1 sends a signal, whether you mean it to or not. When you regularly cancel or deprioritize the conversation, it tells your team this meeting is optional. When that happens, the feedback stops. The coaching stops. The trust erodes.

Consistency builds reliability, and reliability builds performance.

2. The agenda is shared

Managers should come prepared, but they shouldn’t control the whole conversation. Invite your direct reports to shape the agenda with their own wins, blockers, and questions. You’ll learn more about what’s working and what isn’t when you let them lead the dialogue.

3. There’s more listening than talking

Too many managers turn 1:1s into briefings. If you’re talking 80% of the time, you’re missing the point. Use the time to ask, listen, clarify, and coach. Your team should feel like they’re heard, not talked at.

Want to know if your 1:1s are working? Pay attention to how much you’re talking.

4. The questions go deeper than surface-level status

A checklist conversation doesn’t uncover problems. A coaching conversation does.

Instead of defaulting to “What are you working on?”, try:

• What’s feeling unclear right now?

• Where are you stuck?

• Is anything slowing you down?

• What do you need more (or less) of from me?

The answers to those questions will tell you more about team performance than any dashboard.

5. Follow-up isn’t forgotten

1:1s aren’t just conversations. They’re progress markers. If your direct report commits to an action, follow up on it in the next meeting. Not to micromanage, but to reinforce accountability and momentum.

When there’s no follow-through, priorities get lost. When follow-up becomes the norm, expectations stay clear, and performance moves forward.

Why it Matters More Than Ever

In hybrid and high-growth environments, communication gaps widen quickly. 1:1s are your safety net.

They’re where early signals show up: misalignment, confusion, burnout, disengagement. If your managers are waiting for quarterly reviews to address performance, they’re already too late.

1:1s are where small tensions surface before they become conflict. Where minor issues get redirected before they require intervention. And where team members feel seen and supported, before they consider leaving.

If you want your team to perform, your managers need to lead. And if you want them to lead well, start by helping them run a better 1:1.

The Takeaway

One bad 1:1 won’t derail performance. But a pattern of misused (or missed) meetings erodes trust fast, and can create a reactive leadership culture that’s hard to recover from.

If 1:1s are inconsistent, unclear, or underused, you’re not alone. Strengthening foundational habits like this is one of the most common areas we support. At Origami HR, we help businesses put the right rhythms, tools, and training in place so managers can lead with clarity and confidence, consistently.

Need help building stronger people foundations? Book a consult to start the conversation.